If Your Error Messages Confuse Users, You’ve Already Lost

Error messages are often treated as afterthoughts. An edge case. A box to check. But in cybersecurity, they’re something else entirely: they’re the moment your product either builds trust—or blows it.Because when something goes wrong (and it will), the user doesn’t want to read a stack trace or a mystery code. They want to know what happened, why it matters, and what to do next.Instead, they get this:

Error 42. Unknown failure. Please try again later.

Now they’re Googling your product name plus “WTF does Error 42 mean.”

The Breach Before the Breach

Poor error handling isn’t just a UX issue—it’s a security risk. When users don’t understand what’s broken, they guess. They click around. They retry. They disable things. They create tickets. They try again.It’s not just frustrating. It’s dangerous.If the user doesn’t know whether a failed login is due to a typo, expired credentials, or a compromised account, you’ve already lost.

Make the Invisible Visible

Great error messages aren’t just helpful—they’re preventative. They help the user course-correct before a mistake becomes a breach.That means:

  • Clear, human-readable language
  • Context about what went wrong
  • Guidance for what to do next
  • When relevant, a link to a fix or a human

This is not UX polish. This is incident mitigation.The right message at the right moment can prevent an accidental data exposure—or three hours of guessing that ends with someone disabling MFA “just to get in.”

Stop Leaking Context

There’s a balance to strike. Too much detail, and you risk exposing sensitive information to an attacker. Too little, and you leave users in the dark.Design your errors like you're talking to a smart, skeptical colleague. Assume they want clarity but don’t have time to decode it.And for the love of security, never say "invalid password" if it could have been the username. You’re not just frustrating users—you’re helping attackers.

Recoverability Is Security

A user who can recover from failure is a user who won’t file a ticket, reuse a weak password, or go around the system entirely.Your error states are just as important as your success flows. They teach the user how the system works—and whether they can trust it.Bad error handling says: "Something went wrong. Figure it out."Good error handling says: "Here’s what broke. Here’s why. Here’s how to fix it."One leaves users confused. The other leaves them in control. Only one of those is secure.

Comments

No Comments.

Leave a replyReply to

Strategy & Innovation. User Experience & Design. Insights & Analytics. Technology & Engineering.Strategy & Innovation. User Experience & Design. Insights & Analytics. Technology & Engineering.Strategy & Innovation. User Experience & Design. Insights & Analytics. Technology & Engineering.
Strategy & Innovation. User Experience & Design. Insights & Analytics. Technology & Engineering.Strategy & Innovation. User Experience & Design. Insights & Analytics. Technology & Engineering.Strategy & Innovation. User Experience & Design. Insights & Analytics. Technology & Engineering.

Are you ready to build trust through better design?

cartisien_logo_light

© 2025 Cartisien LLC 

Cartisien Interactive